Building Trust in Accreditation: Governance, Transparency, and Accountability
Programmatic accreditors are responsible for making independent, evidence-based judgments about programs’ educational quality. Programs, in turn, must have confidence that accreditation decisions are grounded in established standards and that those standards are applied fairly and consistently, without undue influence. That accreditors have independence to make program judgments is essential to their role in protecting students, the professions they safeguard, and the public.
But accreditor independence should not mean insulation from scrutiny. The credibility of an accreditor depends not only on the standards and policies it establishes and the accreditation decisions it makes, but also how the accrediting organization governs itself, develops and follows its internal policies, and remains accountable to the communities affected by its decisions.
Promoting meaningful accountability in accreditation therefore involves understanding how an accreditor’s policies are developed, who within and outside of the organization participates in those decisions, how feedback is considered, and how the organization uses evidence to improve its own performance.
These expectations are reflected in the PAEA Board of Directors’ Guiding Principles on PA Programmatic Accreditation, which emphasize structural accountability, fair and transparent policies and procedures, appropriate information sharing, and accountability to programs, students, the PA profession, and the public.
Across health professions, different accreditation models offer insight into how these responsibilities can be fulfilled. Some accreditors have established formal relationships with professional organizations while preserving the independence of their accreditation decisions. Others provide structured opportunities for constituent participation or have revisited their governance arrangements in response to evolving expectations.
Together, these approaches raise an important question for PA education: How can an accreditation system preserve the accreditor independence essential to rigorous oversight while ensuring that the organization’s governance, policies, and performance remain open to meaningful evaluation and improvement?
Governance: Establishing Clear Lines of Accountability
An accreditor’s governance structure determines how its leaders are nominated and selected, who establishes standards and policies, who makes accreditation decisions, and who oversees the organization’s performance. These responsibilities may be distributed differently across accreditation systems, but they should be clearly defined and understood.
In PA education, the Accreditation Review Commission on Education for the Physician Assistant (ARC-PA) includes representatives from PA education, clinical practice, medicine, and the public. The ARC-PA publishes its bylaws and policies, as well as information about its commissioners and nominating organizations. Nominating organizations can propose candidates, but sitting commissioners elect new commissioners from a slate advanced by a nominating committee. This distinction matters when considering who has final appointment authority, because a name put forward by a nominating organization may not be presented to the commissioners as a whole.
Medical education offers a different governance approach through the Liaison Committee on Medical Education (LCME), which accredits programs leading to the MD degree. The LCME is jointly sponsored by the Association of American Medical Colleges (AAMC) and the American Medical Association (AMA), establishing a formal relationship between the organizations representing medical education and medical practice and the accrediting body. As described in the LCME Rules of Procedure, the organization’s voting membership includes medical educators and practicing physicians, public representatives, and medical students. Out of the 17 professional members representing medical education and clinical practice communities, eight are elected from nominations provided by AAMC, eight are elected from nominations provided by AMA, and one is elected from nominations provided by LCME.
Under this arrangement, the AAMC and AMA support the accreditation system but do not participate in LCME decisions about individual medical schools. The LCME retains responsibility for its standards, policies, and accreditation decisions. This model illustrates how professional organizations can have defined roles in accreditation governance while preserving the accreditor’s authority over individual program evaluations and decisions.
Beyond how authority is assigned, another consideration is whether governance arrangements are periodically evaluated as professional needs evolve. In physical therapy education, the Commission on Accreditation in Physical Therapy Education (CAPTE) has responded to published critiques regarding the governance of the organization and its relationship with the American Physical Therapy Association (APTA). CAPTE implemented a revised governance structure in January 2026, that includes a central decision-making board supported by specialized review panels.
The CAPTE experience illustrates why governance arrangements warrant periodic examination. Researchers on organizational practices describe how established procedures, leadership practices, and expectations can become entrenched over time, making change more difficult even as needs evolve. Regular evaluation, outside perspectives, and opportunities for new leadership can help organizations assess whether their governance structures continue to provide appropriate oversight, clearly defined authority, and meaningful constituent representation.
Governance accountability also extends to financial stewardship. Programs fund accreditation through fees and other charges, making it important to understand who sets fees, approves budgets, oversees reserves, and decides how resources are used. Responsible stewardship includes funding high-quality reviews and maintaining financial stability, while providing clear explanations of significant fee changes and how resources support accreditation activities.
The PAEA Board’s Guiding Principles explicitly reference LCME’s joint sponsorship model as an example to consider for PA education. More broadly, the examples illustrate that structural accountability does not depend on a single organizational arrangement.
Transparency: Beyond Publicly Available Policies
Transparency is essential to helping programs understand accreditation expectations and participate meaningfully in the processes that shape them.
The ARC-PA publishes its standards, compliance guidance, bylaws, policies, and summaries of accreditation actions. These resources provide important information about the requirements and procedures governing PA accreditation.
However, access to information is only one dimension of transparency. Equally important is understanding how accreditation requirements are developed, how constituent input is considered, and why policies or standards are adopted.
The Commission on Accreditation of Allied Health Education Programs (CAAHEP) offers an example of structured participation by its communities of interest. Its discipline-specific Committees on Accreditation participate in developing and reviewing standards, with proposed revisions subject to public review and hearings before final adoption. These opportunities allow educators, practitioners, institutions, and other interested parties to help inform requirements that will shape education programs.
The next question is what happens after that input is received. For example, when an accreditor proposes revisions to its standards, programs may submit comments identifying potential implementation challenges, suggesting alternative language, or questioning whether a proposed requirement will achieve its intended purpose. Explaining how those comments were evaluated, which recommendations influenced the final standards, and why other proposals were not adopted can make the resulting decisions more understandable.
This context has practical value. Changes to accreditation requirements can affect curriculum, faculty responsibilities, assessment practices, and institutional resources. Understanding the reasoning behind those changes helps programs plan and implement them effectively.
Transparency extends beyond standards development to the procedures available when programs disagree with accreditation findings or decisions.
The ARC-PA maintains established reconsideration and appeals procedures, with available options determined by the accreditation action involved. CAAHEP also has established procedures for program responses to accreditation findings. Programs may respond to findings and correct factual information before a discipline-specific Committee on Accreditation makes its recommendation and the CAAHEP Board takes final action. Although their procedures differ, these approaches demonstrate the importance of clearly communicating when programs may respond to findings, how their responses are considered, and what mechanisms are available to review decisions.
Clarity about those procedures is particularly important when programs must decide whether to pursue an appeal. Programs should be able to find the cost, time limits, permitted grounds, and scope of an appeal, as well as who hears it. Publishing aggregate figures for appeals filed, heard, and resulting in changed decisions could provide valuable insight into how these procedures operate without disclosing confidential program information.
Transparency must also be balanced with confidentiality. Accreditation involves sensitive program information, reviewer assessments, and deliberations that require appropriate protections.
The PAEA Board’s Guiding Principles address this balance through their call for appropriate data sharing with protective firewalls. Clearly defined information-sharing policies can help constituents understand what information may be shared, how it can be used, and what must remain confidential. Making appropriate data available to researchers can also advance the field by supporting independent scholarship, identifying effective educational practices, and generating evidence to inform improvements in educational quality and student outcomes.
Ultimately, transparency is not simply about making more information public. It is about ensuring that programs and other constituents can understand the processes that shape accreditation requirements and decisions, participate where appropriate, access information that supports research and continuous improvement, and have confidence that established procedures are followed.
Accountability: Demonstrating Continuous Improvement
Governance defines responsibilities, and transparency helps constituents understand how those responsibilities are carried out. Accountability also requires an accrediting organization to evaluate its own effectiveness and demonstrate how it uses evidence to improve.
This expectation is familiar to PA programs. Programs must routinely assess educational outcomes, identify areas for improvement, implement changes, and evaluate whether those changes have achieved their intended results. The same commitment to evidence-based improvement is relevant to the organizations responsible for accreditation.
The ARC-PA describes quality improvement activities, including review of program feedback and follow-up on corrective actions, in its published policies. Across accreditation systems, measures such as the timeliness of reviews and decisions, consistency in the interpretation of standards, effectiveness of reviewer training, and recurring concerns identified through program feedback can provide insight into organizational performance. The value of these activities depends not only on gathering information, but also on how that information is used.
Consider a situation in which feedback from multiple programs identifies recurring uncertainty about how a standard is interpreted or where more than half of accredited programs reviewed during the year are cited for noncompliance with a standard. An accreditor might respond by clarifying its guidance, revising reviewer training, or examining whether its review procedures are being applied consistently. Subsequent feedback and review findings could then help determine whether those changes improved understanding and consistency.
Similarly, reviewing the time required to complete accreditation evaluations may identify opportunities to improve scheduling, communication, or decision-making processes. Evaluating the results of those changes provides evidence of whether they have been effective. These examples illustrate how an accreditor can apply continuous-improvement practices to its own operations. They are not findings about the performance of any individual accrediting organization.
An additional consideration is how accreditors communicate the results of this work.
Appropriate summary reporting could identify recurring concerns raised through constituent feedback, describe changes made to policies or procedures, and explain how the organization is assessing their effectiveness. Such reporting can provide useful insight without disclosing confidential program records or individual reviewer evaluations.
This distinction matters because the existence of feedback and quality-improvement processes does not, by itself, tell programs or the public what those processes have accomplished. Demonstrating how findings inform decisions, what improvements have been implemented, and whether those improvements are working provides a clearer picture of organizational accountability.
What These Approaches Mean for PA Education
Accreditation systems across health professions reflect different histories, professional relationships, and governance arrangements. No single model guarantees effective accreditation. However, the governance structures and practices of LCME, CAPTE, and CAAHEP offer useful points of comparison with ARC-PA and demonstrate that greater transparency, clearer accountability, and more meaningful opportunities for professional participation are both achievable and reasonable expectations for PA accreditation.
The PAEA Board’s Guiding Principles bring these considerations together in a vision for accreditation that protects students and the public through rigorous educational standards while ensuring that the organizations responsible for accreditation demonstrate accountability for their own policies, procedures, and performance. The goal is not simply to establish mechanisms for accountability, but to demonstrate that they work.
Continuing the Conversation
PAEA will continue examining accreditation practices across health professions and sharing evidence and approaches that help inform the Board’s Guiding Principles and the broader conversation about the future of PA accreditation.
We also want to hear from members. What should PA programs, educators, and the public be able to learn about how an accreditor selects its leaders, establishes fees, develops standards and policies, and evaluates its own effectiveness? Where should programs and other constituents have opportunities to participate in these processes, and how should their perspectives be considered? What accreditation information and data should be available to support transparency, independent research, and continuous improvement while protecting confidentiality? Finally, what evidence would give members confidence that an accreditor listens to feedback, responds to concerns, and makes meaningful improvements over time?
Your perspectives will help inform this continuing work. Please share your thoughts with the Board of Directors at president@PAEAonline.org.